Policy Versus Virtue In Contemporary Governance: A Philosophical Inquiry From A Christian Ethics Perspective
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.58540/isihumor.v3i4.2731Keywords:
Virtue Ethics, Procedural Liberalism, Policy Governance, Moral Formation, Christian Political TheologyAbstract
Contemporary governance relies on procedural architecture that secures compliance but struggles to cultivate the practical wisdom and civic friendship on which polities depend when rules run out, conflict, or are gamed. This article addresses the implicit claim of proceduralism to self-sufficiency: the assumption that a well-designed policy order can govern well without attending to the moral formation of those who make, administer, and live under it. The study employs conceptual and literature-based analysis through critical hermeneutics, combining close reading of primary texts, conceptual analysis of terms such as policy, virtue, phronesis, ordo, and habitus, and dialectical synthesis of procedural liberalism, neo-Aristotelian virtue ethics, and Christian political theology. No empirical data are generated; claims are advanced as theoretical propositions requiring subsequent empirical examination. The analysis identifies a gap: no coherent model explicitly integrates Christian virtue ethics with practical policy analysis in a way that yields usable analytical categories. The article proposes the Virtuous Policy Governance framework, specifying two novel constructs—the formative dimension of policy and policy-receptive virtue—reframing governance as dynamic interplay between the ordo of policy and the habitus of virtue. The contribution is a constructive synthesis moving beyond the sterile opposition between legal positivism and moral perfectionism, with implications for policy design, institutional culture, and the formation of public officials





